
The Urban Crawl certainly does not traverse the streets every night, as the allure of Tuesday's American Idol has--bear with me--captured my attention.
Typically, I'm good for the awful auditions that smatter us with freak shows and unnecessary drama ("You watch, America! American Idol can kiss my *&#!") as the dearly departed exit the premises. But something special, whether it's local "talent" (more on that later) or salty-haired blues singers that look like their back hurts when they sing, has me completely immersed in an office pool and a Wednesday morning water cooler conversation.
Allow me to step aside from the nightlife feature to offer my take on the top ten, and for entertainment purposes only, a shot at handicapping the field. As of the time of this posting, the 3/28 show has concluded for voting.
Bucky Covington (25,000:1) There's simply no way this bottom-feeder, with limited vocal ability, will escape the cut in the next week or two. His silly mike toss, the mid-song squat that looks like he passed uncomfortable gas, and a country music pigeonhole performance wouldn't even be the best singer on a Saturday night at the Yellow Rose.
Lisa Tucker (10,000:1) Who is she? Resembling wallpaper, we seem to forget her weekly performance, and her age (16) pushes the maturity barrier for the demands of an Idol winner. A lack of stage presence doesn't help, and her recent rendition of "Because of You" by Kelly Clarkson should do her in on whatever week Bucky doesn't go.
Ace Young (5,000:1) Already having been threatened to be sent home in the bottom three, his smoldering good looks simply do not mask his cheesy song-concluding icy stares (enough of that, already) and poor song selections. Although he sits in the top ten, the production crew probably offered a gentle nudge to the judges to consider his contribution to the ratings.
Elliott Yamin (750:1) Until last week's departure of Chicken Little, he's the least attractive contestant, with slight improvement after losing the leprechaun beard. The military-grade haircut and a train wreck of teeth won't overcome his decent lyrical ability, and he needs to overcome the hip-hop delivery his body conveys despite a different song theme.
Kellie Pickler (250:1) America's sweetheart survives even this long only on her ditsy demeanor and blonde locks, because her wooden delivery and basic country ability couldn't even win in Charlotte's "Gimme the Mike!" contest on WSOC-TV last year. Also, she's the target subject of www.votefortheworst.com, a website that mocks a contestant and encourages her vote. It didn't work long for Kevin Covais, but he wasn't hot like her, so she might crack the top five.
Taylor Hicks (30:1) The last five candidates are a tight race of talent, and will hopefully be the remaining five in weeks to come. Taylor is a professional recording artist, and perhaps his snowy hair already exhibits the signs of a man on the road. Two weeks of unimpressive performances has his star falling rapidly, and honestly, although you enjoy his stage antics, do you want a blues artist clutching the trophy?
Mandisa (20:1) The pool's second-best voice has almost rendered her weight, a subject of Simon's ridicule, as moot. But the hyprocisy of Hollywood, and the viewers of the show, probably won't elect this diva despite the uncanny victory of Ruben Studdard over Clay Aiken in season two.
Paris Bennett (10:1) This sparky little fireplug, a 17 year old from Georgia, consistently delivers a top-notch performance, and arguably occupies the spot formerly held by Taylor. Astonishing diversity in her performances, and perhaps the best stage presence of the bunch, might make her the dark horse. Contrary to Lisa Taylor, this teen exudes the confidence of a star.
Katharine McPhee/Chris Daughtry (5:1) Too close to call, Katharine's effortless performances (I mean, she did Christina Aguilera!) and Chris' rocker bad boy shtick leave their audiences shrieking. Katharine doesn't have quite the force of Chris' assembly of past weeks' blowouts, but I think she's quietly positioning herself to emulate Kelly Clarkson like Simon once mentioned. Selfishly, she's also the subject of my secret crush, but I am also a rocker by trade. I'll take either.
Do you agree? Post a reply, or email me at charlottenightlife@hotmail.com. Back to the beers next time.